News 
 Local News 
 News 
 Politics 
 Mayor calls for recess over foreshore outburst 

Mayor calls for recess over foreshore outburst

31 Aug, 2009 05:24 PM
A 30 minute recess had to be called in the middle of last week's Redland City Council general meeting, after outbursts from councillors and members of the 50-strong public gallery over the Redland Bay Town Centre and Foreshore master plan, which was adopted without any changes.

Nine speakers, all from the islands, spoke of their concerns, including feeling insufficiently consulted since the draft plan was opened for consultation 10 months ago.

They also feared residents could be priced off the islands by paid parking.

President of the Moreton Bay Combined Islands Association (MBCIA), Mark Edwards, criticised council's decision to have a private consultation with the SMBI Community Advisory Committee (SMBICAC), describing it as a "council implement", and asked for a delay on the report so the MBCIA could present an alternative.

But Mayor Melva Hobson was forced to adjourn councillor debate for 30 minutes after the public gallery shouted for Division 7 councillor Murray Elliott to apologise after he made personal remarks about Russell Island resident and former councillor Frank Bradley, who had spoken earlier.

Cr Elliott withdrew the remarks, but refused to apologise, and when Mr Bradley refused to settle after the recess, he was escorted out by chief executive officer Gary Stevenson.

Taunting from the gallery started at the beginning of the meeting, when Deborah Wagner, from the Redlands Easter Festival, described councillors as "God-appointed leaders in this community" during the devotional segment.

"Don't see the criticism, see the crowd. Is the criticism widespread or is it coming from one person?"

The plan was eventually adopted, with Bay Islands Division 5 councillor Barbara Townsend reiterating her comments from last week's planning and policy committee, where the plan was debated at length.

"It's eight years since we started on this plan and we must move forward.

"But as parts of this plan are implemented there will be ongoing community consultation. In the meantime, I urge anyone with questions about the plan to contact me."

Councillors John Burns and Karen Williams signalled an intention to move a deferment but were unsucessful.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
The BB reports "A 30 minute recess had to be called..." and "Mayor Melva Hobson was forced to adjourn councillor debate...".

Had to - was forced...says who?

Reads like lines straight out of a Mayoral media release. Printed as gospel and not checked?

What clearly happened at this meeting was another example of Mayor Hobson not being able to control a meeting and after 2 plus years still not knowing procedure.

What was clearly on display was that all Councillors (and remember most belong to Team Hobson) have no respect for the Mayor.

Other options were at her disposal to bring the meeting to order, but she took the 30 minute recess with the hope that most in the public gallery would go home.

Flawed, desperate thought.

Mr Bradley actually left the meeting at his own will, as he did not want to let down fellow residents who'd come to hear the decision.

Your photo shows the CEO explaining the options to Mr Bradley.

On the lighter side, many a laugh was had by all particularly when the 'flustered-disrespected' Mayor repeatedly called Mr Bradley "Councillor Bradley".

And yes you got to wonder about Councillors laughing at their leader.

The Redlands feels the frustration too.

Posted by Jan, 31/08/2009 9:20:45 PM, on Bayside Bulletin
The foreshore masterplan is a no-brainer. Islanders will not pay parking fees. Nor will the visiting public.

And Redland Bay residents can kiss a marina good bye. The council cannot keep up with demand and islanders will need short terem free parking.

Besides, private enterprise would not get bank finance to provide multi-level parking as the new ILTP is likely to recommend shorter links to the islands away from the present ferry terminals.

It is about time ferry and barge operaters realised that if they want to extend their businesses into the mid-term they will need new terminal facilities closer to the islands. Otherwise I can feel the islands will revolt and form their own councils to put in viaducts to circumvent needless parking fees and ferry services.

Posted by Mud Crab of Macleay Island, 1/09/2009 12:07:41 AM, on Bayside Bulletin
Well written Jan, I wished I'd been there. Doesn't sound too professional. They bandy around this 'community consultation' but having just received an example of it (long story) I can tell you it's just a pr exercise and they will do what they (and carp) want.
Posted by jumpy, 1/09/2009 9:12:36 AM, on Bayside Bulletin
I was there! Pity the media report is inaccurate. There were at least 65 in the 'gallery'.

Cr Murray Elliott was the only person who did NOT adhere to Mayoral guidelines of speaking during the General Meeting.

The Mayor cannot control a meeting. To ask the CEO to remove Frank Bradley was ridiculous. Only a qualified Security Officer can do that!

Councillors smirking at a serious subject just shows their commitment to the residents. All proves how inefficient this Council operates.

Posted by cazruss, 1/09/2009 11:20:34 AM, on Bayside Bulletin
Selfishness is not living as one wishes to live, it is asking others to live as one wishes to live. - Oscar Wilde.

Does this sound like the current green council?

Selfishness does not win elections.

Posted by Barbara S, 1/09/2009 11:21:38 AM, on Bayside Bulletin
Can someone please tell me why we had all the meetings with promises of consultation and wanting so much to listen to the island residents and then this: "The Redland Bay Town Centre and Foreshore master plan, which was adopted without any changes". And they wonder why people become cynical and angry.

It WAS all just a PR stunt after all with never an intention of changing a thing.

They are all amateurs, short-sighted, dishonest and not resident-friendly.

All yuppy and comfy in their rich little worlds with no idea or worse still, care, what so ever on how their short-sighted decisions are going to impact the islands.

And to think I had hope and voted for them. Never again. One day, I hope these islands and the Redlands will get a council and mayor which will have vision and be just and honest and compassionate - perhaps a little more like the Ipswich mayor.

Redlands sucks bigtime.

Posted by Stephen de Weger, 1/09/2009 1:28:54 PM, on Bayside Bulletin
I was there. I heard Mr. Bradley say that, if the Mayor wanted him removed, she should call the police. But obviously, nobody had the guts to do so.

It was the Councillor for Div. 5, who has moved the motion.

Her and eight of her fellow councillors’ conduct, including the Mayor’s, resembles more that of a dictatorship than that of democracy, we are constantly made believe we are living in.

One wonders, why the RCC has called for submissions in the first place, when it had no intention to heed the advice and alternatives offered by the public.

In a totalitarian state, such contempt for the rights and needs of its citizens does not come as a surprise, but in a democracy it is unacceptable, if not unconstitutional.

Posted by ngudooroo, 1/09/2009 1:34:11 PM, on Bayside Bulletin
What a bunch of hypocrites.

One minute they vote for a proposal, that virtually takes away the absolutely necessary commuter car parks at Weinam Creek Marina, the Gateway to the Southern Moreton Bay Islands by charging them a fee they cannot afford, and the next minute the same bunch of hypocrites cries out for the State Government to supply free commuter car parking at a railway station.

Have they lost the plot?

But wait, there is more.

The Councillor for Cleveland and Stradbroke Island is crying foul, when there is talk about charging the same car parking fees for commuters at Toondah Harbour, the Gateway to Straddie.

Posted by napoleon, 1/09/2009 3:28:41 PM, on Bayside Bulletin
For Cr. Elliott to compare Redland Bay Foreshore & Marina with Circular Quay, Sydney, just shows how out of touch and uncaring he is.

Circular Quay can be accessed by ROAD from all sides of Sydney. We do not have that option!!

Posted by cazruss, 1/09/2009 4:19:12 PM, on Bayside Bulletin
Wasn't Frank Bradley the same dude that was responsible for the pigs comment that cost us money in terms of a payout to the three female councilors concerned.

Well done Frank and due to your performance the RCC is the only local government authority to be awarded a discrimination ruling under this provision of the Act.

Please stay on the island and shut up!

Posted by Tool Time, 1/09/2009 8:46:23 PM, on Bayside Bulletin
1 | 2  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
DIVISION 5 councillor Barbara Townsend responds to criticism of the Redland Bay Town Centre Master Plan.
DIVISION 5 councillor Barbara Townsend responds to criticism of the Redland Bay Town Centre Master Plan.
REDLAND City Council chief executive officer Gary Stevenson confronts former councillor Frank Bradley after Mr Bradley was asked to leave.
REDLAND City Council chief executive officer Gary Stevenson confronts former councillor Frank Bradley after Mr Bradley was asked to leave.

Most popular articles




 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...